Chapter 10

The Scorecard

The reference, written down before the deal instead of muttered after it. The seller rates the buyer on seven lines and the buyer rates the seller on six, each line defined so a five means the same thing to everyone. Read and sign it at the letter of intent; score it at closing, after the ninety days, and over the life of the note.

Rating the buyer

Filled in by the seller. His rating of the buyer works like a credit report and a character reference at the same time.

What is being judgedThe questionA five looks likeA one looks like
Offer integrityDid the deal that closed match the deal that was offered?Closed on the letter of intent, on time, nothing re-tradedPrice or terms re-traded late, or walked away
CloseabilityCould he actually do what he offered?Funds and financing ready, and a record of offers that closeFinancing fell apart, or delays put the deal at risk
Paying the sellerDid he pay what he owed, when he owed it?Every payment on time; every performance payment calculated honestly and paid in fullLate or missed payments, disputes in bad faith, surprise requests to restructure
StewardshipHow did he treat what the seller built?Kept the key people, kept the customers, honored the seller's nameCleaned house, lost customers, disrespected the legacy
The handoffHow did he work with the seller during the transition?Used the seller's knowledge, communicated, respected the seller's roleShut the seller out or ignored the handoff plan
The business after closeDid the business hold up? This one protects the seller's note.Revenue and profit held or grewA decline driven by the buyer's decisions
CharacterHow did he act under pressure?Honest, kept his word, told the truth when it was hardMisled, blamed others, broke promises

Offer integrity and paying the seller carry the most weight, and a buyer who re-trades the price or pays late can never score a five, however well he runs the business.

Would you sell to him again?

Rating the seller

Filled in by the buyer. The categories mirror the buyer's: honest books, a real handoff, and staying a partner while the note is paid.

What is being judgedThe questionA five looks likeA one looks like
DisclosureWas the business what the seller said it was?Clean, honest financials; the problems disclosed up frontHidden liabilities, inflated numbers, surprises after close
Deal integrityDid the seller honor the terms he agreed to?Stuck to the letter of intent; no shopping the deal, no late demandsRe-opened the terms, stalled, or backed out
Transferring the trustDid he hand over the customers, the employees and the vendors?Personal introductions; the relationships moved to the new ownerThe relationships stayed with the seller; key people or customers walked
Showing upDid he show up for the ninety days?Present, teaching, available, and stepped back on scheduleChecked out early, or would not let go
Support while the note is paidDid he stay a partner after the handoff?Answers the phone, protects the reputation, does not compete or recruit the staffUndermined the new owner, competed, or poached people
CharacterHow did he act under pressure?Owned the weaknesses, credited the team, kept his wordBlamed others, misled, broke promises

Disclosure and transferring the trust carry the most weight.

Would you buy from him again?

When: both sides read and sign the scorecard at the letter of intent, before anything is scored. At closing, score the first lines (offer integrity and closeability for the buyer; disclosure and deal integrity for the seller). After the ninety days, score the transition lines. The last two lines keep scoring over the life of the note. Every thirty days for the ninety, sit down with it together and talk about it honestly: a coaching session, both directions.

Print it: the scorecard as a two-page sheet (PDF), one page for each chair, with the boxes to fill in.

Not legal advice. The mutual non-disclosure agreement, the letter of intent and the purchase agreement come from your attorney.